Friday, October 16, 2009

More Sun Ignorance on Congestion

Gridlock

Photo by lynac

The Toronto Sun once again has proven its ignorance toward gridlock issues in Toronto. Mike Strobel’s column this morning argues that we should be timing our traffic lights to improve traffic flow but not for TTC vehicles or bicycles.

What Mr. Strobel fails to comprehend is that any modest improvement in traffic flow on Toronto’s streets will be met by an equal amount of new cars on the road. This is the same reason that adding more lanes to Toronto highways will only make gridlock worse.

It’s simple: the demand for roads will always exceed the capacity (in Toronto) - that is a reality.

Strobel refers to Hamilton’s timed lights working well to keep traffic flowing. Of course it works well in Hamilton because there are less cars. In Toronto there are millions of people who take the GO train, TTC or bike to work. At any given moment any of these people could easily jump in their car and take it to work – if traffic flow was improved.

This is simply not the case in Hamilton. Some day in the future Hamilton demand will exceed the capacity of road space, but until then timed lights will work well.

Furthermore, Strobel also fails to understand that timed traffic lights can only work on one-way streets. Toronto has very few one-way streets, so converting the two-way streets would be necessary to even make his suggestion possible. The last thing I’d want to see is King street or Queen street turn into a Richmond or Adelaide. It would remove all liveability from these streets.

This is the problem with simpleton media like the Toronto Sun. You can’t expect any kind of analysis from some of the writers – only emotional drivel. That’s why the Sun thinks there is a war on cars, but the truth is that investment in bicycle infrastructure and public transit is the only way to reduce gridlock.

You need to provide people an alternative to driving, otherwise our roads will always be over-capacity.

2 comments:

  1. Toronto's expressway infrastructure sucks compared to Montreal's maze of expressways. I've live in both cities and Toronto is totally lacking in expressways. Just go to google maps and use the street view camera and you will see the difference immediately.

    Ontario has been feeding Quebec Billion$$$ in equalization payments, and they have built up Montreal tremendously while Toronto sucks the hind teat. It's so obvious.
    ReplyDelete
  2. Love your site, but you are dead wrong on this. Toronto has been hijacked by a moronic mentality that thinks it is necessary to hinder vehicle traffic. That's why Transit City (streetcars on suburban avenues) is a priority over the Downtown Relief Line, which can be accomplished mostly with existing rail corridors.

    Transit needs to be the first option, but please don't give me Adam Vaughan-inspired garbage about one-way streets. Ever been to New York, Montreal, Chicago, Hong Kong or pretty much any other major city on this planet? Notice the one-way streets in their downtown cores? Are those cities "unlivable?"
    ReplyDelete